Idea and concept: Daniel Tibor Fuchs
Text developed and refined with the support of artificial intelligence
Final review: Daniel Tibor Fuchs

On Monday, Harvard published in Nature Sustainability a study on 403 of the largest data centers in the United States, observed between May 2024 and April 2025. The number that will travel the world is a strong one: 25.7 million tons of CO2 in one year, more than Denmark emits.
The headline writes itself: "data centers pollute more than a country". But anyone who reads the study calmly finds a different story.
The researchers did not measure smoke coming out of the buildings. The CO2 in the count comes from the power plants that feed each region's grid. And 54% of that electricity comes from fossil fuels, with 38% from natural gas and 15% from coal.
What a data center emits on its own is close to nothing. It is basically emergency diesel generators, which stay off most of the time. In Google's case, direct emissions are below 1% of the company's carbon footprint.
In other words, a data center is a customer of the grid, like a factory or a hospital. If the grid is dirty, it is dirty. If the grid is clean, it is clean. The same building, with the same machines, emits a lot or almost nothing depending on where it is plugged in.
This is where Brazil comes in. In 2025, renewables supplied 86.8% of the country's electricity, according to the National Energy Balance published by EPE (source). Our power sector emitted about 65 kg of CO2 per MWh. The data centers in the Harvard study run on electricity at about 545 kg per MWh. The same data center, plugged in here, would emit roughly eight times less.
The country has already noticed. Redata, Brazil's tax regime for data centers signed into law in September, ties its tax benefits to running entirely on renewable or low emission energy. The fight now is over whether natural gas counts. I think it should not. Our advantage is precisely clean energy.
Of course, despite these arguments, data centers do have an influence, since they already account for about 1.8% of US electricity, and demand is growing fast. In many places, they are what keeps gas and coal plants running longer. There are also the emissions from making the chips and building the facilities, and at Google the supply chain reaches 80% of the total. Even in Brazil, thermal power generation grew again in 2025. None of this is small.
But the conclusion stays the same. Fighting data centers is fighting the symptom. In 2025 Google used 37% more electricity and still cut its operational emissions by 2%, a result the company credits to its clean energy purchases. It is possible to grow and clean up at the same time.
What I stand for:
Push big tech to bring new clean energy, contracted along with each data center, and not just certificates.
Demand that governments invest in clean generation and transmission at the pace of demand.
Choose locations by the quality of the grid. Virginia, Oregon, Ohio and Iowa account for more than half of the consumption studied, and many facilities sit in areas with heavy coal generation.
Bring data centers to Brazil, without giving up Redata's renewable energy requirement.
Stop treating the data center as the villain. The right question is where the energy comes from.

